ChatGPT’s Groundbreaking Legislation to Govern AI in Costa Rica Sparks Debate Among Experts

• Blockchain Council
• July 14, 2023

In a groundbreaking move, Costa Rican politicians have turned to ChatGPT, an advanced language model developed by OpenAI, to assist in the creation of legislation to regulate artificial intelligence (AI) in the country. This unique approach has sparked a heated debate among experts and lawmakers, highlighting the growing importance and complexity of governing AI systems.

The initiative, led by Congresswoman Vanessa Castro, aimed to address the pressing need for AI regulation while leveraging the capabilities of ChatGPT to draft a comprehensive bill. Congress instructed the chatbot to “think like a lawyer” and draft legislation in line with the country’s constitution. Subsequently, the final document was presented to the legislature in its entirety.

Castro expressed both optimism and concerns about the initiative, stating, “We have had many positive reactions and many people who thought it to be very risky.” This polarizing response reflects the ongoing discourse surrounding AI regulation and the role of technology in shaping the future of governance.

ChatGPT’s proposed legislation emphasizes the establishment of an independent body responsible for overseeing AI systems in Costa Rica. This regulatory entity would be guided by principles such as accountability, explainability, bias prevention, and the protection of human rights. These values align with the growing consensus among experts that AI must be governed with transparency and fairness.

Also read: Blockchain Development with AI

The bill was formally introduced in May, marking a significant milestone in Costa Rica’s efforts to address the challenges posed by AI. However, before it proceeds to the parliamentary commission for further revisions and debate, the legislation is currently undergoing open discussions in public forums. This inclusive approach ensures that diverse perspectives and expertise are considered before finalizing the bill.

One of the main criticisms of the proposed legislation comes from Congresswoman Johana Obando. While supporting the idea of AI regulation, Obando raised concerns about ChatGPT’s methodology, alleging that the chatbot fabricated facts and provisions from the national constitution. Moreover, she criticized the bill for being a mere “list of good wishes” lacking substantive measures, a common apprehension expressed in Latin America regarding AI legislation.

In response to these criticisms, ChatGPT highlights the importance of regulating AI based on fundamental rights and international conventions. Obando emphasized the need to explicitly reference these rights and conventions in the bill to ensure a solid foundation for governing AI systems. This ongoing debate underscores the complexity of AI regulation and the necessity of addressing key ethical considerations.

Latin American legislators are closely monitoring the European Union’s AI Act as a source of inspiration for their own regulatory efforts. The EU’s legislation includes provisions prohibiting AI technology’s use in biometric surveillance and mandating transparency in AI-generated content. Taking cues from the EU, Mexico filed a bill in March advocating for an ethical framework in AI development, emphasizing the protection of human rights and personal data. However, like the Costa Rican bill, the specific details of the ethical framework remain to be defined through public forums and expert discussions.

Also read: AI Interview QnA PDF

Peru recently took a significant step in AI regulation by approving the region’s first comprehensive law governing AI. The law, based on principles of digital security and ethics, establishes a national authority to oversee AI development. Congressman Jose Cueto, who spearheaded the introduction of the bill, stressed the importance of creating an environment conducive to ethical, transparent, and sustainable AI use.

The broader discussions on AI regulation across the region reveal several interconnected concerns. Racism and discrimination have emerged as critical issues, prompting debates on preventing algorithmic bias and ensuring equitable outcomes. In Brazil, for instance, ongoing debates about AI regulation have highlighted the need to protect marginalized populations from potential harm caused by AI systems. These discussions underscore the necessity of diverse representation and inclusive decision-making processes to address the concerns of racial and ethnic minorities.

The discussions also shed light on the concept of AI colonialism, which refers to the dominance of multinational corporations in shaping AI technologies and products. Experts advocate for the promotion of local innovation and competition with multinational giants. Initiatives such as creating a regulatory sandbox in Brazil aim to foster local experimentation with AI technology in controlled environments, empowering domestic businesses to develop solutions tailored to the specific needs and cultures of Latin American societies.

To ensure comprehensive AI regulations, lawmakers must tackle the multifaceted challenges associated with bias, discrimination, and the influence of multinational corporations. Collaboration among stakeholders, including policymakers, AI experts, and representatives from marginalized communities, is vital for shaping inclusive and effective legislation.

Costa Rica’s pioneering approach of utilizing ChatGPT to draft AI legislation has sparked a significant dialogue and engagement on the regulation of emerging technologies. The ongoing debate and public consultations demonstrate the commitment to creating a robust framework for AI governance that upholds fundamental rights, fosters innovation, and safeguards against potential harm.

As Latin American countries navigate the complexities of AI regulation, their experiences serve as valuable lessons for other nations grappling with similar challenges. The ultimate goal is to strike a delicate balance that encourages technological advancement while ensuring the ethical, transparent, and responsible use of AI for the benefit of society as a whole.

Also read: The Ultimate AI Glossary: Unraveling the Jargon and Concepts of Artificial Intelligence